Side income
Day trading doesn’t make you a trader: how the IRS sees it
Nearly everyone who trades from a phone or a laptop is an investor in the eyes of the tax law, with a $3,000 limit on losses and no deduction for expenses. What it takes to be a trader, what that gets you, and the election that has to be made before the year starts.
By Charles Trautman, EA · Reviewed November 18, 2026
People who trade often assume that trading a lot makes them a business. Usually it does not. The tax law puts almost everyone who buys and sells stocks and options for their own account in the category of investor, however many trades they make. An investor’s losses are capped at $3,000 a year against other income, wash sales postpone losses, and nothing spent on the activity is deductible. A small number of people qualify as traders, and an even smaller number have made the election that changes how their losses are treated.
Three categories
| Investor | Trader | Trader with the mark-to-market election | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gains and losses | Capital, on Form 8949 and Schedule D | Capital, on Form 8949 and Schedule D | Ordinary, on Form 4797 |
| Net loss against other income | $3,000 a year | $3,000 a year | No $3,000 limit |
| Wash sale rule | Applies | Applies | Does not apply |
| Expenses (data, software, home office) | Not deductible | Deductible on Schedule C | Deductible on Schedule C |
| Long-term capital gain rates | Available | Available | Not on trading positions |
| Self-employment tax | No | No | No |
Worked example: a $30,000 losing year, three ways
Wages of $90,000 and a net trading loss of $30,000.
| Investor | Trader | Trader with the election | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loss deducted this year | $3,000 | $3,000 | $30,000 |
| Carried to later years | $27,000 | $27,000 | $0 |
| Federal tax saved this year at 22% | $660 | $660 | $6,600 |
The investor’s $27,000 is not lost. It carries forward without limit of time, absorbing future capital gains in full and $3,000 a year of other income. But at $3,000 a year it takes nine more years to use against wages alone.
What makes someone a trader
There is no election for trader status and no form to file. It is a question of fact, and the courts have set the bar high. All of these have to be true:
- You aim to profit from short-term price swings, not from dividends, interest or long-term growth.
- Your trading is substantial: in the decided cases, many hundreds of trades a year, and often more than a thousand.
- It is frequent, regular and continuous: on most days the market is open, all year, with holding periods measured in days. People with hundreds of trades have lost in court because they traded on fewer than half the market days, or stopped for months.
- You give it the time a business takes. A full-time job elsewhere makes the claim hard, though not impossible.
A trader without the election gains one thing: expenses of the activity become business deductions on Schedule C. Gains and losses are still capital, and the $3,000 limit and the wash sale rule still apply.
The mark-to-market election
A trader can elect to treat every position as if it were sold at its market value on the last business day of the year. Gains and losses become ordinary. That removes the $3,000 limit and the wash sale rule, and gives up long-term capital gain rates on the trading account.
The deadline is what catches people. The election for a year must be made by the due date of the prior year’s return, without extensions. For 2027 that is April 15, 2027, by a statement attached to the 2026 return or to the extension request. An election for 2026 had to be made by April 15, 2026. It cannot be made after a losing year to rescue that year’s losses. Once made, it stays in force until the IRS agrees to revoke it.
Investments you want taxed as long-term holdings must be kept in a separate account and identified as such on the day you buy them.
For everyone else: the rules that bite
- Wash sales. Sell at a loss and buy the same stock or option within 30 days before or after, and the loss is postponed. An active trader can end the year with a taxable gain on the 1099-B while the account is down, because losses in December were followed by repurchases in January. Buying in an IRA or a spouse’s account counts. See Reading your brokerage 1099: basis, wash sales, corrected copies.
- Short-term gains are taxed as ordinary income. There is no lower rate for anything held a year or less. See Capital gains: how your gains are taxed.
- Nothing is withheld. A profitable year needs estimated payments. See Estimated payments: who has to make them, and the safe harbor.
- The 3.8% tax on investment income applies to trading gains at higher incomes.
- Futures and broad index options are taxed under their own rule: marked to market at year end and treated as 60% long-term and 40% short-term whatever the holding period, reported on Form 6781.
- Crypto has its own reporting. See The digital asset question.
Trading inside an IRA avoids all of it: no reporting of gains, no wash sale tracking, and no deduction for losses either.
Behind the scenes
A preparer asked to treat a client as a trader counts first: the number of trades, the number of days traded, the average holding period, and the months with no activity, all of which come from the broker’s year-end data. If the numbers fall short, the return is filed as an investor’s, because a Schedule C full of expenses and no income is one of the patterns the IRS looks for. If they hold up, the preparer asks whether the election was made on time and looks for the statement in last year’s file. The 1099-B is then reconciled to the broker’s own gain and loss report, since wash sales across accounts are the client’s to track, not the broker’s.
The Colorado side
Colorado starts from federal taxable income, so trading gains are taxed at the flat 4.40% and the $3,000 loss limit carries over from the federal return unchanged. Colorado has no lower rate for long-term gains. A federal loss carried forward is used on the Colorado return in the same year it is used federally.
What to bring your preparer
- Form 1099-B from every account, including the detail pages
- The broker’s year-end realized gain and loss report
- Form 1099 composite pages showing wash sale adjustments
- If you claim trader status: trade counts, days traded, and a list of expenses
- A copy of any mark-to-market election statement and the return it was filed with
- Last year’s return, for the capital loss carried forward
Preparer’s notes
For the Tax Shop desk · code sections, forms and the things that get missed
- Trader status: facts and circumstances; Higgins, Moller, Holsinger, Endicott (1,543 trades and 112 days in the best year still lost), Poppe (won). Document trades, days, holding period, hours.
- §475(f): election by the unextended due date of the prior year’s return, Rev. Proc. 99-17; Form 3115 with the first-year return. New taxpayers: statement in the books within 75 days. Late relief under Reg. §301.9100-3 is rarely granted.
- Reporting: Form 4797 Part II for MTM gains and losses; expenses on Schedule C; no SE tax (§1402(a)(3)(A)). Trading is not QBI in substance (§199A(c)(3)(B)) and is an SSTB.
- Segregation: §475(f)(1)(B); investment positions identified by the close of the day acquired.
- §1091: wash sales across accounts and into IRAs (Rev. Rul. 2008-5). Broker reporting covers one account and identical CUSIPs only.
- §1256: 60/40; three-year loss carryback election for individuals, Form 6781 box D.
- §163(d): investor margin interest is investment interest on Form 4952; a trader’s is a Schedule C expense.
- §461(l): the excess business loss limit applies to MTM trading losses.
Questions people ask
I made 600 trades last year. Am I a trader?
Not on the count alone. How many days you traded, how long you held, and whether you kept it up all year matter as much.
Can I deduct my trading subscriptions and a home office?
Only as a trader. For an investor, those costs have not been deductible since 2018, and that was made permanent in 2025.
I lost $50,000 this year. Can I make the election now?
No. It is too late for this year. You can make it by April 15 for next year if you qualify as a trader, but it will not reach back.
Should I set up an LLC to trade through?
An LLC does not change whether the activity is trading. It can make a new election easier to time, since a new entity may elect within 75 days of starting. It also adds a return and a cost.
Do I owe self-employment tax on trading profits?
No, in any of the three categories. Trading gains are also not earned income for an IRA contribution.