Tax Shop
Lone Tree, Colorado

Tax Shop › Topics

Side income

RSUs, stock options and the employee stock plan: why the W-2 and the 1099-B disagree

Stock from an employer is taxed twice in time, once as pay and once as an investment, and the two forms that report it do not agree with each other. How RSUs, options and stock purchase plans work, and how to avoid paying tax on the same dollars twice.

By Charles Trautman, EA  ·  Reviewed November 18, 2026

When part of your pay comes in company stock, the value is taxed as wages and shows up in box 1 of your W-2. Later, when the shares are sold, the broker sends a 1099-B. On a great many of those 1099-Bs the cost shown is zero or far too low, because the broker is not allowed to count the amount you were already taxed on as wages. Entered as it arrives, that form taxes the same income a second time. This is the most common expensive mistake on returns with stock pay, and it is entirely avoidable.

The four kinds, and when each is taxed

Taxed as wagesYour cost basis in the sharesForm to keep
RSUs (restricted stock units)When they vest, on the full value that dayThe value on the vesting dateVesting confirmation; W-2
Nonqualified stock optionsWhen you exercise, on the spread between the price you pay and the valueWhat you paid plus the spread taxed as wagesExercise confirmation; W-2 box 12 code V
Incentive stock options (ISOs)Not at exercise for regular tax; possibly for the alternative minimum taxWhat you paid, for regular taxForm 3921
Employee stock purchase plan (ESPP)When you sell, on some or all of the discountWhat you paid plus the discount taxed as wagesForm 3922

Worked example: 200 RSUs, and a 1099-B that says the cost was zero

200 units vest when the stock is at $100. The company keeps 60 shares for taxes and you sell the other 140 the same day.

As the 1099-B reports itCorrected
Added to W-2 wages at vesting$20,000$20,000
Sale proceeds, 140 shares$14,000$14,000
Cost basis$0$14,000
Gain on the sale$14,000$0
Extra federal tax at 22%$3,080$0

The $14,000 was already taxed as wages. The correction is made on Form 8949 with an adjustment to basis, using the figure on the vesting confirmation or the supplemental statement the stock plan sends alongside the 1099-B.

RSUs: the withholding gap

Employers withhold on vesting stock at a flat 22%, usually by keeping some of the shares. If your pay puts you in the 24%, 32% or 35% bracket, the gap comes due in April, and on a large vest it can be thousands of dollars. Either sell enough shares at vesting to set the difference aside, raise the withholding on your regular paycheck, or make an estimated payment. See Estimated payments: who has to make them, and the safe harbor.

Shares you keep after vesting are an ordinary investment from that day. A later rise is capital gain, long-term if you hold more than a year from vesting; a fall is a capital loss. One trap: selling company shares at a loss within 30 days before or after a new vest is a wash sale, and the loss is postponed.

Options

Nonqualified options. The spread at exercise is wages, with Social Security and Medicare tax, whether or not you sell. Exercising and holding means paying tax on value you have not turned into cash.

Incentive stock options. Exercise is not a taxable event for regular tax. If you hold the shares more than one year after exercise and more than two years after the grant, the whole gain is long-term capital gain. Sell sooner and the spread at exercise becomes wages.

The catch is the alternative minimum tax. If you exercise ISOs and still hold the shares at year end, the spread counts as income for the AMT, and a large exercise can produce a large tax bill on stock you have not sold. From 2026 the AMT exemption shrinks faster for higher incomes, starting at $500,000 single and $1,000,000 joint, so more option holders are exposed than in recent years. AMT paid this way generally comes back as a credit in later years. See What carries over.

The employee stock purchase plan

You buy at a discount, usually up to 15%, through payroll. Nothing is taxed at purchase. At sale, part of your profit is wages and the rest is capital gain, and the split depends on how long you held: more than two years from the start of the offering period and more than one year from purchase gives the better result. Either way, the wage part is added to your cost basis, and the 1099-B usually leaves it out. Employers sometimes fail to put the wage part on the W-2 of someone who has left; it is taxable all the same.

Two elections with short deadlines

The 83(b) election applies to restricted stock, actual shares that can be forfeited, and not to RSUs. Filed within 30 days of the grant, it taxes the shares at today’s value instead of the value at vesting. It suits founders and early employees whose shares are worth little now. It cannot be undone, and if the shares are forfeited the tax paid is not refunded.

Leaving the company. Vested options commonly expire 90 days after your last day, and an ISO exercised more than three months after leaving is taxed as a nonqualified option. See Between jobs: the tax decisions in the first 60 days.

Behind the scenes

A preparer works a stock-pay return from three documents the client often does not think to bring: the year-end pay stub or W-2 detail showing how much stock income is inside box 1, the stock plan’s supplemental statement with the adjusted cost basis for each sale, and Forms 3921 and 3922. Each sale on the 1099-B is matched to a vesting or purchase lot and the basis corrected on Form 8949. For ISOs the preparer runs Form 6251 before the client exercises, if asked in time, because the size of the AMT can be controlled by how many options are exercised in one year and cannot be changed afterward.

The Colorado side

Colorado starts from federal taxable income and taxes it at a flat 4.40%, so stock pay is taxed here when and as it is taxed federally. Colorado also has its own alternative minimum tax, so a large ISO exercise that triggers the federal AMT should be checked on the Colorado return as well. If you earned an award while working in another state and it vested after you moved to Colorado, or the reverse, each state can tax a share based on your workdays; see Moving to Colorado: part-year returns and residency.

What to bring your preparer

  • Form 1099-B and the stock plan’s supplemental or “adjusted cost basis” statement
  • The final pay stub of the year, showing stock income included in wages
  • Form 3921 for each ISO exercise and Form 3922 for ESPP shares transferred
  • Vesting and exercise confirmations for the year
  • Last year’s return, for any AMT credit carried forward
  • A copy of any 83(b) election you filed

Preparer’s notes

For the Tax Shop desk · code sections, forms and the things that get missed

  • Basis: Reg. §1.6045-1(d)(6)(ii) bars brokers from including compensation in reported basis for awards granted after 2013. Form 8949 code B, column (g) adjustment. Check every lot.
  • RSU: §83(a) at vest. Supplemental withholding 22%, 37% above $1 million. Net-share settlement: only the shares delivered appear on the 1099-B.
  • NSO: §83; W-2 box 12 code V. ISO: §421/§422; Form 3921; AMT adjustment on Form 6251 line 2i; dual basis (regular and AMT) until sold; Form 8801 for the credit.
  • Disqualifying ISO disposition: ordinary income limited to actual gain on an arm’s-length sale; no FICA; confirm it reached the W-2.
  • ESPP: §423. Qualifying: ordinary income is the lesser of actual gain or the discount measured at the offering date. Disqualifying: the spread at purchase, even at a loss.
  • §83(b): 30 days, no extension; Form 15620 or a statement; copy to the employer.
  • Wash sales: a vest or ESPP purchase is an acquisition for §1091.
  • State: allocate by workdays from grant to vest (options: grant to exercise in most states) when the client moved.

Questions people ask

My RSUs vested and I did not sell. Do I owe tax?

Yes. The value at vesting is wages whether or not you sell. It is already in your W-2.

The 1099-B box says the basis was “not reported to the IRS.” Does that matter?

It means the IRS does not have a basis figure, so nothing will be matched against yours, but you still must report the correct one. Use the supplemental statement.

Should I sell RSU shares as soon as they vest?

For tax purposes there is no penalty for doing so: the gain since vesting is near zero. Whether to hold is an investment decision about owning more of the company that also pays your salary.

I exercised ISOs and the stock then fell. Do I still owe AMT?

If you held past December 31, the AMT is figured on the value at exercise. Selling in the same calendar year as the exercise removes the AMT problem and turns the spread into wages.

I moved to another state between the grant and the vest. Which state taxes it?

Often both, each on a share based on where you worked while the award was being earned. Bring your dates.

Forms and official pages named in this article

Sources and where to check

Updated November 18, 2026 · tax year 2026 figures
General information about federal and Colorado income tax for the 2026 tax year, as the law and IRS guidance stood on November 18, 2026. It is not advice about your return. Congress, the IRS and the annual inflation figures change; where something here matters to you, confirm it with a professional who knows your facts. How these articles are written.

Paid partly in stock?

Bring the 1099-B, the supplemental statement and your last pay stub. We will correct the basis on every sale, check the withholding gap, and run the alternative minimum tax before you exercise. In person in Lone Tree or remotely, year round.