Tax Shop
Lone Tree, Colorado

Tax Shop › Topics

Side income

The marriage bonus, the marriage penalty, and your first joint return

Married on December 31 means married for the whole year. Who pays less as a couple, who pays more, and the five things to change before the first joint return.

By Charles Trautman, EA  ·  Reviewed November 18, 2026

Your filing status for the whole year is decided on one day: December 31. Marry on New Year’s Eve and you are married for all twelve months; the choice is then between a joint return and two separate ones, and filing as single is no longer available. For most couples the joint return costs the same as two single returns or less. For some it costs more. Which you are depends mostly on how alike your two incomes are.

Bonus or penalty

The joint brackets and the joint standard deduction are exactly double the single ones up through the 35% bracket. That has two effects. Two people with similar incomes pay the same tax married as they did single. And when one earns most of the income, the lower earner’s unused low brackets and standard deduction shelter the higher earner’s pay, and the couple’s tax falls.

Worked example: $140,000 of pay, two ways

2026 brackets and standard deductions, no children, no other income.

One earns $140,000, the other nothingEach earns $70,000
Federal tax as two single people$22,334$13,140
Federal tax on a joint return$13,140$13,140
Difference from marrying$9,194 lessnone

The one-earner couple gets the bonus because a second standard deduction and a second set of 10% and 12% brackets are put to use. The two-earner couple sees no change in the tax itself, though their withholding still needs attention; see below.

The penalty comes from the rules that are not doubled for a couple. These are the ones that catch people:

Five things to do before the first joint return

  1. Report a name change to Social Security first. The IRS matches the name and number on the return against Social Security’s records. A return filed under a new name that Social Security does not have yet is rejected.
  2. Give both employers a new W-4. Each payroll system withholds as if its paycheck were the couple’s only income. With two jobs, both of you check the box in Step 2(c), or the couple comes up $2,000 to $5,000 short in April. See The W-4: getting withholding right.
  3. Tell the Marketplace, if either of you buys coverage there. Marriage opens a 60-day window to change plans and changes the credit from the month of the wedding.
  4. Update beneficiaries on retirement accounts and life insurance. Those forms, not the will, decide who receives the money.
  5. Ask each other about old debts. A joint refund can be taken for one spouse’s past-due taxes, child support or defaulted student loans. The other spouse can protect their share with Form 8379. See Injured spouse and innocent spouse relief.

What marriage gives you

If each of you owns a home when you marry and you sell one, the seller can still exclude up to $250,000 on the joint return, as long as that spouse meets the ownership and use tests alone.

Filing separately

A married couple can file two returns. It rarely lowers the total tax, because the law takes away or cuts most credits on a separate return: the earned income credit in most cases, the education credits, the student loan interest deduction, and most of the child care credit. Social Security benefits are taxed from the first dollar if you lived together, the Roth IRA income limit drops to $10,000, and if one of you itemizes the other must.

The reasons it is still chosen are mostly not about the tax itself: student loan payments that are based on income, one spouse’s large medical bills measured against a smaller income, or not wanting to sign for the other’s return. A joint return makes each spouse responsible for all of the tax on it. Run the return both ways before deciding.

Behind the scenes

For a first joint return a preparer pulls both prior-year returns, because they answer most of the questions: a capital loss or other carryover one spouse brings in, estimated payments made under one Social Security number, an IRA contribution that the other’s workplace plan now limits, a refund that was applied forward. The preparer also checks which name Social Security has on file, since that is the most common reason a newlywed return is rejected, and looks at both final pay stubs to see whether the W-4s were ever changed.

The Colorado side

Colorado taxes income at a flat 4.40% and starts from federal taxable income, so there is no marriage penalty in the Colorado rate itself, and a couple uses the same filing status on the Colorado return as on the federal one. Colorado recognizes common-law marriage. A couple who are married under that rule are married for federal tax as well, and must file as married.

What to bring your preparer

  • Last year’s return for each of you
  • The date of the marriage, and whether Social Security has been told of any name change
  • All W-2s and 1099s for both, and both final pay stubs
  • Form 1095-A, if either of you had Marketplace coverage in any month
  • Student loan details, if either of you is on an income-based payment plan
  • Any letters about past-due taxes, child support or federal student loans
  • If a home was sold: the closing statements for the purchase and the sale

Preparer’s notes

For the Tax Shop desk · code sections, forms and the things that get missed

  • Status: §7703(a), determined at year end. Colorado recognizes common-law marriage; a common-law couple is married for federal purposes (Rev. Rul. 58-66) and cannot file single.
  • Name/SSN: e-file reject on mismatch. File under the name SSA has.
  • Prior-year AGI: each spouse’s own prior-year AGI or IP PIN signs the first joint e-file.
  • Carryovers: capital loss, NOL, charitable, passive and credit carryovers come in from each separate return; keep them traceable by spouse in case of later separate filing or death.
  • MFS: §32(d) EITC (limited exception for separated spouses), §25A(g)(6), §221(e)(2), §21(e)(2), §86(c)(1)(C), §408A(c)(3), §63(c)(6)(A). SALT cap $20,200. Run both ways; compare total federal and Colorado.
  • Offsets: Form 8379 with the return when one spouse has past-due federal or state tax, child support or federal non-tax debt.
  • Home sale: §121(b)(2); $500,000 needs both to meet use, either to meet ownership. Otherwise each spouse’s $250,000 is tested separately on the joint return.
  • Estimates: payments made under one SSN before marriage are claimed on the joint return; list both SSNs if a notice follows.

Questions people ask

We married in December. Can we each file as single for that year?

No. Married on December 31 is married for the year. The choice is joint or separate.

Do I have to change my name with the IRS?

No. Tell Social Security, and use the name Social Security has when you file. If the change has not gone through by the time you file, file under the old name.

Am I responsible for tax my spouse owed before we married?

No. But a joint refund can be taken to pay it. Form 8379, filed with the return, keeps your share.

We both have children from before. Who claims them?

On a joint return they are all on one return, so the question goes away for the two of you. It remains with each child’s other parent. See Who should claim the child?

Should we wait until January to marry?

For two high earners, two retirees on Social Security, or a parent receiving the earned income credit, a January wedding can save real money for one year. For a couple with one main earner, a December wedding saves it. Work it out before setting the date, if the date is flexible.

Forms and official pages named in this article

Sources and where to check

Updated November 18, 2026 · tax year 2026 figures
General information about federal and Colorado income tax for the 2026 tax year, as the law and IRS guidance stood on November 18, 2026. It is not advice about your return. Congress, the IRS and the annual inflation figures change; where something here matters to you, confirm it with a professional who knows your facts. How these articles are written.

First joint return?

Bring last year’s return for each of you and your final pay stubs. We will run the return jointly and separately, fix both W-4s, and check for anything that could reach a joint refund. In person in Lone Tree or remotely, year round.